Why Women May Want to Return to Full-Fat Dairy Products
I remember when we made the switch.
Whole milk, which had been a staple of the American diet for decades, was bad for our hearts, the experts told us. It contained too much fat that could clog our arteries. Other full-fat dairy products, too, like cottage cheese, yogurt, pudding, and cheese also increased risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, obesity, and cancer.
Low-fat options were the way to go for good health, they assured us.
So my family replaced our full-fat milk jug with a one-percent milk fat option instead. We also started buying low-fat versions of other dairy products, until buying full-fat seemed an indulgence, at best, and dangerous, at worst.
It was a bit of an adjustment. The products tasted different, more watery. But when you’re talking about your long-term health, you understand that sometimes you need to make sacrifices. And after awhile, we all got used to it.
But recently, there have been some rumblings in the scientific world.
Could it be that they had it all wrong?
Are the full-fat versions of dairy products actually better for us?
Recent Studies Suggest Full-Fat Dairy May Be Healthier
Recent research has examined the relationship between dairy foods and obesity, cardiovascular disease, and type 2 diabetes. Scientists have found surprising results.
In one study review, for example, those who consumed high-fat dairy products were less likely to be obese. They were also no more likely to develop cardiovascular disease or type 2 diabetes than those who ate low-fat dairy products.
“The observational evidence,” the researchers wrote, “does not support the hypothesis that dairy fat or high-fat dairy foods contribute to obesity or cardiometabolic risks, and suggests that high-fat dairy consumption within typical dietary patterns is inversely associated with obesity risk.”
In other words, low-fat dairy doesn’t seem to be any healthier than high-fat dairy, and may actually be less healthy in some ways.
Other studies have shown similar results. Scandinavian researchers followed about 1,500 men aged 40-60 years over a 12-year period. They found that a low intake of dairy fat was actually associated with a higher risk of developing obesity, while a high intake of dairy fat was associated with a lower risk of obesity—the exact opposite of what we’ve been lead to believe would happen.
Seems we could also potentially reduce risk of type 2 diabetes if we ate more full-fat dairy products. In a recent 2016 study, researchers reported that participants with a higher circulating blood level of dairy fat had a 44–52 percent lower risk of type 2 diabetes than those with a lower blood level of dairy fat.
An earlier 2014 study showed similar results—those who ate the most high-fat dairy products had a 23 percent lower risk of developing type 2 diabetes than those with the lowest consumption. A third study found that eating more high-fat yogurt and cheese could reduce risk of type 2 diabetes by as much as a fifth.
Does Low-Fat Fail to Protect Women from Heart Disease?
Heart disease remains the number-one killer of women, and we’ve all been taught that the best way to avoid it is to cut back on fat. But more recent studies are questioning that logic, too.
In 2016, for instance, scientists reported that a higher fat DASH (Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension) diet actually lowered blood pressure the same as the regular DASH diet, but then also reduced triglyceride levels and did not raise LDL “bad” cholesterol levels.
In another 2016 study, researchers looked at data from over 200,000 participants and found no link between high-fat dairy foods and risk of cardiovascular disease. In an earlier review examining the relationship between milk fat and cardiovascular health, researchers found that most studies failed to find a link between the intake of dairy products and an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, coronary heart disease, or stroke.
Does this mean that women can go back to eating full-fat dairy products without having to worry about negative health consequences?
Should Women Be Concerned About Full-Fat Dairy?
There are plenty of reasons for women to be concerned about eating too much fat.
Breast cancer is one of them. In 2013, researchers reported that patients who consumed high-fat dairy products after getting a breast cancer diagnosis were more likely to die from the disease years later. An earlier study also found that intake of animal fat, mainly from red meat and high-fat dairy foods, was associated with an increased risk of breast cancer.
Other studies have linked intake of high-fat dairy products to other types of cancer, like ovarian cancer, but the results have been mixed. Whereas a 2004 study found a link between intakes of dairy products and risk of certain types of ovarian cancer, a 2013 study did not. In fact, in that study, researchers reported that a high intake of calcium (often from dairy products) reduced risk of ovarian cancer.
Results on breast cancer, too, haven’t always been consistent. A pooled analysis from over 20 studies found no link between dairy product intake and breast cancer risk.
Still, the fact that even some studies have found a connection can leave women feeling worried. Even if recent studies show that full-fat dairy products don’t affect heart disease risk and may even protect against obesity and type 2 diabetes, there are those other studies showing the exact opposite.
So what are women supposed to do?
The Whole Fat-Health Connection is More Complicated Than Expected
Here are some things to consider.
When manufacturers began to take the fat out of dairy products, they often replaced it with sugar to make it taste better. That means that while we were getting less fat, we were getting more sugar, which we now know may actually be more harmful when it comes to our health.
Studies have also found that when we eat less fat, we tend to eat more sugar and simple carbohydrates to compensate for the lack of fat in our diets. Both of these are known to increase inflammation—which is linked to heart disease and cancer—and to increase risk of diabetes.
All that sugar also seems to have a more detrimental affect on our weight than fat does. In a 2016 study of over 18,000 women over the age of 45, researchers found that greater intake of high-fat dairy products (but not low-fat dairy products) was associated with less weight gain.
In a review of 39 studies, researchers found that higher intakes of sugar not only increased risk of obesity, but also raised triglyceride levels, increased total cholesterol levels, and increased blood pressure.
The problem is that when experts started telling us to cut out the fat in our diets, they didn’t realize that we’d have resulting cravings that would compel us to replace them with other bad stuff. Scientists failed to take the human diet as a whole into consideration.
The theory now is that maybe, when we eat full-fat dairy products, we don’t feel as many cravings for sugary foods. Fat tends to satisfy. In fact, foods that can make us feel full have been largely ignored until now as being important to our health. Full-fat dairy products are more satisfying than low-fat dairy when it comes to fullness, and that alone could help us to better manage weight and our risk of cardiovascular disease.
You’ve heard the advice to eat more avocadoes, walnuts, flaxseed, and fatty fish, for example. That’s because these foods contain what are called “healthy fats” that we now know can help protect the heart, blood vessels, and brain.
It could be that dairy fats, too, can help improve the way our cells break down sugar from food, which would have an overall positive effect on our health. Certain high-fat dairy foods that are fermented, like yogurt and cheese, can help improve insulin response, which would decrease risk of type 2 diabetes. Fatty acids from dairy foods may play a role in hormone regulation, and may help limit how much fat the body stores.
What About Dairy Products and Hormones?
There’s something else that’s concerning about dairy products, however: hormones.
We know from scientific research that there is a link between cancer and hormones, estrogen in particular. Unfortunately, much of the milk we buy in the store has hormones in it. Cow’s milk, according to Harvard researchers, contains considerable amounts of female sex hormones.
This is because most dairy farms in the U.S. keep their cows pregnant to keep them producing, and milk from pregnant cows contains higher hormone levels than milk from nonpregnant ones.
Since hormones reside in fat, the concern is that full-fat dairy products will have more hormones.
Could this be why some studies have found a link between the consumption of full-fat dairy products and an increased risk of some cancers?
We don’t know for sure yet. Remember that many studies have found no link between dairy products and cancer, and some have even found dairy products to be protective against some cancers. But it is something to keep in mind.
Women Can Feel Good About Adding Some Fat Back Into Their Diets
How do we balance what we know about full-fat dairy and women’s health with what we don’t know?
For now, scientists advise women not to go whole-hog on full-fat dairy, but to consider replacing some of their low-fat items with higher-fat alternatives to try to go for a more well-balanced diet.
You may want to swap your one-percent for whole milk, for example, or choose full-fat yogurt and cottage cheese (since these are fermented products and likely healthier anyway). If eating high-fat dairy options help you eat less sugar and carbs overall, that’s another reason to eat more of them—especially if you find that you lose weight when doing it.
Every woman is different, so your best bet is to experiment a little bit and see what’s best. What you don’t want to do is see fat as the enemy anymore. We have too much evidence showing that it can help protect you against disease. It’s still wise to limit your consumption so you’re not packing on the extra calories, but it might also be smart to add back in a few items you enjoy to see how they affect you.
In addition, look for healthier options that are likely to have fewer hormones. That means products that come from organically raised, grass-fed cows. You may also want to consider raw milk (that hasn’t been pasteurized) in some cases, because it contains healthy enzymes, but do consider the source so you don’t expose yourself (or your family) to dangerous microbes. If you’re at all concerned, go for pasteurized.
Mario Kratz, et al., “The relationship between high-fat dairy consumption and obesity, cardiovascular, and metabolic disease,” European Journal of Medicine, February 2013; 52(1):1-24, http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs00394-012-0418-1.
Holmberg S., Thelin A., “High dairy fat intake related to less central obesity: a male cohort study with 12 years’ follow-up,” Scand J Pim Health Care, June 2013; 31(2):89-94, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23320900.
Mohammad Y. Yakoob, et al., “Circulating Biomakers of Dairy Fat and Risk of Incident Diabetes Mellitus Among US Men and Women in Two Large Prospective Cohorts,” Circulation, March 22, 2016; 134(18): http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/early/2016/03/22/CIRCULATIONAHA.115.018410.abstract.
Diabetologia, “Consumption of high-fat dairy products associated with lower risk of developing diabetes,” ScienceDaily, September 15, 2014, https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/09/140915202955.htm.
Ulrika Ericson, et al., “Food sources of fat may clarify the inconsistent role of dietary fat intake for incidence of type 2 diabetes,” American Society for Nutrition, May 2015; 101(5):1065-1080, http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/101/5/1065.
Sally Chiu, et al., “Comparison of the DASH (Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension) diet and a higher-fat DASH diet on blood pressure and lipids and lipoproteins: a randomized controlled trial,” American Society for Nutrition, February 2016; 103(2):341-347, http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/103/2/341.
Peter J. Huth and Keigan M. Park, “Influence of Dairy Product and Milk Fat Consumption on Cardiovascular Disease Risk: A Review of the Evidence,” Advances in Nutrition, May 2012; 3:266-285, http://advances.nutrition.org/content/3/3/266.full.
Kaiser Permanente, “High-fat dairy products linked to poorer breast cancer survival,” ScienceDaily, March 14, 2013, https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/03/130314180136.htm.
Susanna C. Larsson, et al., “Milk and lactose intakes and ovarian cancer risk in the Swedish Mammography Cohort,” Am J Clin Nutr, November 2004; 80(5): 1353-1357, http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/80/5/1353.full.
“Melissa A. Merritt, et al., “Dairy foods and nutrients in relation to risk of ovarian cancer and major histological subtypes,” Int J Cancer, March 1, 2014; 132(5);1114-1124, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3495088/.
Cho E., et al., “Premenopausal fat intake and risk of breast cancer,” J Natl Cancer Inst., July 16, 2003; 95(14):1079-85, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12865454.
Missmer SA, et al., “Meat and dairy food consumption and breast cancer: a pooled analysis of cohort studies,” Int J Epidemiol, February 2002; 31(1):78-85, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11914299.
Susanne Rautiainen, et al., “Dairy consumption in association with weight change and risk of becoming overweight or obese in middle-aged and older women: a prospective cohort study,” American Society for Nutrition, February 24, 2016; 103(4):979-988, http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/early/2016/02/24/ajcn.115.118406.
Lisa A. Te Morenga, et al., “Dietary sugars and cardiometabolic risk: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials of the effects on blood pressure and lipids,” Am J Clin Nutr, 2014; doi: 10.3945/acjn.113.081521, http://www.drperlmutter.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Am_J_Clin_Nutr-2014-Te_Morenga-ajcn.113.081521-1.pdf.
Hassan Malekinejad, Aysa Rezabakhsh, “Hormones in Dairy Foods and Their Impact on Public Health—a Narrative Review Article,” Iran J Public Health, June 2015; 44(6):742-758, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4524299/.